BUTLER BROTHERS LLC

USDOT 3320251 • 3460 NARROW PAVED RD, LYNCHBURG, SC, 29080

ACTIVEMotor Carrier

Authority:1 active

Insurance:1 current

BOC-3:On file

Safety Rating:Not rated

MCS-150:Never updated

OOS Orders:None

Overview

Company profile from FMCSA Census File

USDOT

3,320,251

Status

ACTIVE

Operation

Interstate

Business Type

Motor Carrier

State

South Carolina

Phone

8435500101

[email protected]

Power Units (MCS-150)

Drivers (MCS-150)

MCS-150 Mileage

50,000

BOC-3 Agent

DOTPROCESSAGENTS.COM LLC

Physical Address

3460 NARROW PAVED RD, LYNCHBURG, SC, 29080

Mailing Address

3460 NARROW PAVED RD, LYNCHBURG, SC, 29080-9682

Contact

Phone: 8435500101

Email: [email protected]

Authority & Insurance

Operating authority, insurance filings, and BOC-3 status

Common Carrier — Active

Active Authority

Revoked / Inactive

Authority Types

Insurance Policies

1 active

Latest: Apr 11, 2025

BOC-3 Filing

On file

Operating Authority

fmcsa-authhistApr 5, 2026

Operating Authority
Authority Type	Docket #	Status	Original Date	Final Date
Common Carrier	MC-1056334	ACTIVE	Unknown	Nov 5, 2025

Active Insurance (1)

fmcsa-insurApr 5, 2026

Active Insurance (1)
Insurer	Type	Policy #	Status	Effective	Cancel Date
CANAL INSURANCE CO.	BIPD/Primary	CT8414222516	ON FILE	Apr 11, 2025	Nov 5, 2025

Insurance History (23 canceled/expired)

fmcsa-inshist-allwithhistory

Insurance History (23 canceled/expired)
Insurer	Type	Policy #	Status	Effective	Cancel Date
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-03773	CANCELLED	Feb 5, 2025	Apr 1, 2025
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-03773	CANCELLED	Aug 29, 2024	Feb 13, 2025
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-03773	REPLACED	Aug 29, 2024	Feb 5, 2025
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Aug 8, 2024	Aug 29, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	CANCELLED	Jun 14, 2024	Aug 29, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Jun 14, 2024	Aug 8, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	CANCELLED	Apr 4, 2024	Jul 4, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Apr 4, 2024	Jun 14, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	CANCELLED	Feb 15, 2024	May 7, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Feb 15, 2024	Apr 4, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	CANCELLED	Dec 4, 2023	Mar 6, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Dec 4, 2023	Feb 15, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	REPLACED	Aug 29, 2023	Dec 4, 2023
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-02348	CANCELLED	Aug 29, 2023	Jan 1, 2024
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-01387	REPLACED	Jan 24, 2023	Aug 29, 2023
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-01387	REPLACED	Dec 7, 2022	Jan 24, 2023
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-01387	CANCELLED	Dec 7, 2022	Feb 9, 2023
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-01387	REPLACED	Aug 29, 2022	Dec 7, 2022
BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	BIPD/Primary	FLCA-1926-01387	CANCELLED	Aug 29, 2022	Dec 16, 2022
CANAL INSURANCE CO.	BIPD/Primary	341275001	REPLACED	Aug 29, 2021	Aug 29, 2022
AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	BIPD/Primary	LHT08219-02	CANCELLED	Aug 29, 2020	Aug 29, 2021
AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	BIPD/Primary	08219-1	CANCELLED	Oct 27, 2019	Aug 29, 2020
AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	BIPD/Primary	08219-1	CANCELLED	Aug 29, 2019	Oct 27, 2019

Insurance Events Timeline

fmcsa-insur-hist

Insurance Events Timeline
Event	Insurer	Policy #	Type	Event Date	Cancel Date
CANCEL	CANAL INSURANCE CO.	CT8414222516	BIPD/Primary	Nov 5, 2025	Nov 5, 2025
CANCEL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-03773	BIPD/Primary	Apr 1, 2025	Apr 1, 2025
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-03773	BIPD/Primary	Feb 13, 2025	Feb 13, 2025
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-03773	BIPD/Primary	Feb 5, 2025	Feb 5, 2025
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2024	Aug 29, 2024
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2024	Aug 29, 2024
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Aug 8, 2024	Aug 8, 2024
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Jul 4, 2024	Jul 4, 2024
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Jun 14, 2024	Jun 14, 2024
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	May 7, 2024	May 7, 2024
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Apr 4, 2024	Apr 4, 2024
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Mar 6, 2024	Mar 6, 2024
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Feb 15, 2024	Feb 15, 2024
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Jan 1, 2024	Jan 1, 2024
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-02348	BIPD/Primary	Dec 4, 2023	Dec 4, 2023
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-01387	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2023	Aug 29, 2023
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-01387	BIPD/Primary	Feb 9, 2023	Feb 9, 2023
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-01387	BIPD/Primary	Jan 24, 2023	Jan 24, 2023
TERM/CANCL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-01387	BIPD/Primary	Dec 16, 2022	Dec 16, 2022
TERM/REPL	BENCHMARK INSURANCE COMPANY	FLCA-1926-01387	BIPD/Primary	Dec 7, 2022	Dec 7, 2022
TERM/REPL	CANAL INSURANCE CO.	341275001	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2022	Aug 29, 2022
CANCEL	AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	LHT08219-02	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2021	Aug 29, 2021
CANCEL	AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	08219-1	BIPD/Primary	Aug 29, 2020	Aug 29, 2020
CANCEL	AMERICAN MILLENNIUM INS/CITADEL REINSURANCE	08219-1	BIPD/Primary	Oct 27, 2019	Oct 27, 2019

Authority Revocations

fmcsa-revocations

Authority Revocations
Authority	Docket	Reason	Date
COMMON	MC-1056334	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Unknown

Authority Action History (13 events)

fmcsa-authhist-blob

Authority Action History (13 events)
Docket	Authority Type	Original Action	Served Date	Disposition	Decided Date
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Oct 9, 2025	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Nov 5, 2025
MC1056334	MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIER	REINSTATED	Apr 15, 2025	—	Unknown
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Jan 17, 2025	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Feb 6, 2025
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Aug 2, 2024	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Aug 9, 2024
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Jun 7, 2024	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Jun 17, 2024
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Feb 8, 2024	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Feb 16, 2024
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Jan 13, 2023	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Jan 25, 2023
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Nov 21, 2022	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Dec 8, 2022
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Aug 2, 2022	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Aug 22, 2022
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Aug 2, 2021	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Aug 31, 2021
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Aug 3, 2020	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Aug 25, 2020
MC1056334	COMMON	INVOLUNTARY REVOCATION	Sep 30, 2019	DISCONTINUED REVOCATION	Oct 3, 2019
MC1056334	MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIER	GRANTED	Sep 5, 2019	REVOKED	Apr 7, 2025

Safety & Inspections

SMS BASIC scores, inspection history, and out-of-service rates

SMS BASIC Scores

Hours of Service

N/A

Unsafe Driving

88%

Higher percentile = worse safety performance relative to peers. Scores at or above 75% trigger FMCSA alerts.

Inspections

Violations

7 OOS

Vehicle OOS %

21.4%

Driver OOS %

7.1%

Above nat'l avg (6.7%)

Power Units (MCS-150)

Drivers (MCS-150)

Crash Records

Inspection Activity (24 months)

Monthly inspection counts with OOS months highlighted. Hover bars for details.

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

Clean monthMonth with OOSBased on latest 14 of 14 inspection records

Inspection Activity Map

2 states • 14 inspections

None Low Medium High🚛 Home base

Violation Summary (59 violations from 14 inspections)

fmcsa-inspection-file

Violation Summary (59 violations from 14 inspections)
Code	Description	# Violations	# OOS	Severity Wt	BASIC
FMCSR:393.9(a)	Inoperable required lamps	11	2	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.17C-PI	No proof of periodic inspection	6	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2	Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued	5	0	8	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:396.17(c)	No proof of periodic inspection	3	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75C-TAOTD-LT2/32	Tire tread depth insufficient (other axles)	2	0	5	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.78	Windshield condition defective	2	0	4	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45	Brake tubing/hoses inadequate	2	1	7	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55(e)	Coupling device/towing methods defective	2	0	8	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:395.22(h)(4)	Driver failed to maintain supply of blank drivers records of duty status graph-grids	2	0	—	Hours Of Service
FMCSR:393.9A-LSLI	Inoperable required lamps	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LHWS	Lighting devices/reflectors	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LSLM	Lighting devices/reflectors	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.78A-WS	Windshield condition defective	1	0	4	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LHWS	Inoperable required lamps	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LTSIR	Inoperable required lamps	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LTSM	Lighting devices/reflectors	1	1	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LCL	Inoperable required lamps	1	0	3	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45B2-BHTD	Brake tubing/hoses inadequate	1	1	7	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48A-BMBCBD	Inoperative/defective brakes	1	0	8	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLIFTA	Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued	1	0	8	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:392.2-SLLIRP	Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued	1	0	8	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.207F-SASMD	Suspension - Air spring/bag is missing or is detached at the top or bottom.	1	1	—	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLLR	Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued	1	0	8	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:392.16-D	Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)	1	0	3	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:383.23A2-LCDLN	License (CDL) - Operate a CMV and does not possess a valid CDL	1	1	—	Driver Fitness
FMCSR:393.75(c)	Tire tread depth insufficient (other axles)	1	0	5	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16(a)	Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)	1	0	3	Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:395.22(g)	Portable ELD not mounted in a fixed position and visible to driver	1	0	—	Hours Of Service
FMCSR:395.22(h)(2)	Driver failing to maintain ELD instruction sheet	1	0	—	Hours Of Service
FMCSR:393.95(f)	Emergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper	1	0	—	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.203(e)	Cab front bumper missing/unsecured/protrude	1	0	—	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75(a)(1)	Tire-ply or belt material exposed	1	0	—	Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:395.22(h)(1)	Driver failing to maintain ELD user's manual	1	0	—	Hours Of Service

Peer Context

This carrier vs national averages. Lower is better for all metrics.

Vehicle OOS Rate

21.4%vs nat'l 23.4%

-2.0 pts below avg

Driver OOS Rate

7.1%vs nat'l 6.7%

On par with national average

Violations / Inspection

4.21vs nat'l 1.80

+2.41 above avg

National averages: vehicle OOS 23.4%, driver OOS 6.7%, violations per inspection ~1.8. Based on FMCSA MCSAP program data.

Inspection History (14 inspections)

fmcsa-inspectionsApr 5, 2026

Inspection History (14 inspections)
Date	Report #	Station	State	Level	Vehicle	Violations	Top Codes	OOS
Nov 19, 2025	86393083	HOLLY HILL SC	SC	Level 2	FREIGHTLIN TRUCK TRACTOR	17	396.17C-PI, 393.75C-TAOTD-LT2/32, 393.9A-LSLI	Yes
Sep 11, 2025	85756609	FLORENCE SC	SC	Level 3	FREIGHTLIN TRUCK TRACTOR	3	396.17C-PI, 392.2-SLLLR	No
Aug 1, 2025	85409376	LUMBERTON WEIGH STATION, I-95,	NC	Level 3	FRHT TRUCK TRACTOR	0	—	No
Jul 23, 2025	85327324	WEST COLUMBIA SC	SC	Level 3	FREIGHTLIN TRUCK TRACTOR	3	396.17C-PI, 392.16-D	No
Nov 20, 2024	83202782	LYNCHBURG SC	SC	Level 3	LUFKIN TRA SEMI-TRAILER	1	383.23A2-LCDLN	Yes
Aug 20, 2024	82447671	I-26 EB ROADSIDE	SC	Level 2	FRHT TRUCK TRACTOR	10	393.9(a), 393.45, 393.78	Yes
Jul 30, 2024	82256061	US 521 SUMTER COUNTY	SC	Level 3	FRHT TRUCK TRACTOR	1	392.16(a)	No
Jul 23, 2024	82201871	UNION	NC	Level 3	TRAO SEMI-TRAILER	0	—	No
Oct 4, 2023	79831369	I-20 EB ROADSIDE	SC	Level 2	TRAO SEMI-TRAILER	19	393.9(a), 392.2, 396.17(c)	No
Sep 21, 2023	79730074	I-20 WB DARLINGTON COUNTY	SC	Level 3	VOLV TRUCK TRACTOR	0	—	No
Sep 14, 2023	79662612	US 76 FLORENCE COUNTY	SC	Level 3	VOLV TRUCK TRACTOR	0	—	No
Aug 3, 2023	79328386	US 76 SUMTER COUNTY	SC	Level 3	TRAO SEMI-TRAILER	0	—	No
May 8, 2023	78555359	US 70 NEAR NC 58	NC	Level 2	VOLK STRAIGHT TRUCK	1	393.9(a)	Yes
Apr 12, 2023	78329211	US PRIMARY	SC	Level 3	—	4	392.2, 395.22(h)(1), 395.22(h)(4)	No

Inspection analytics

Monthly cadence, frequent stations, and violation mix

Inspections per month (24 mo)

8 total · 37.5% OOS

2024-072025-11

InspectionsOOS

Most frequent inspection stations

LUMBERTON WEIGH STATION, I-95,1

UNION1

US 70 NEAR NC 581 · 1 OOS

FLORENCE SC1

HOLLY HILL SC1 · 1 OOS

I-20 EB ROADSIDE1

I-20 WB DARLINGTON COUNTY1

I-26 EB ROADSIDE1 · 1 OOS

Violations by BASIC category

Vehicle Maintenance43 · 6 OOS

Unsafe Driving10

Hours of Service5

Driver Fitness1 · 1 OOS

Recent Crashes

2 crash records from FMCSA Crash File

Total Crashes

Fatalities

Injuries

Across 2 crashes

Tow-Aways

Crash History (2 records)

fmcsa-crash-fileApr 5, 2026

Crash History (2 records)
Date	State	Severity	Fatalities	Injuries	City	Location	VIN	Carrier Name at Crash
Nov 19, 2025	SC	INJURY	0	3	BOWMAN	87SB	...N22698	BUTLER BROTHERS LLC
Mar 13, 2021	SC	INJURY	0	1	GRESHAM	US378	...U10744	BUTLER BROTHERS LLC

Compliance Timeline

27 events merged from authority, insurance, enforcement, OOS, crash, MCS-150, and safety rating records

Nov 19, 2025

Crash

Injury crash in SC

0 fatalities, 3 injuries

Nov 5, 2025

Authority

Common Carrier authority active

Docket MC-1056334

Nov 5, 2025

Insurance

Insurance cancel

CANAL INSURANCE CO. • BIPD/Primary

Apr 1, 2025

Insurance

Insurance cancel