COMPLETE AUTO RECOVERY SERVICES INC

USDOT 1767517 • 503 NORTH STREET, MIDDLETOWN, NY, 10940

ACTIVEMotor Carrier
Authority:1 active
Insurance:2 current
BOC-3:On file
Safety Rating:Not rated
MCS-150:Never updated
OOS Orders:None

Overview

Company profile from FMCSA Census File

USDOT
1,767,517
Status
ACTIVE
Operation
Interstate
Business Type
Motor Carrier
Phone
8454674600
Power Units (MCS-150)
4
Drivers (MCS-150)
4
MCS-150 Mileage
90,000
Physical Address
503 NORTH STREET, MIDDLETOWN, NY, 10940
Mailing Address
BOX 4754, MIDDLETOWN, NY, 10941
Contact

Authority & Insurance

Operating authority, insurance filings, and BOC-3 status

Common Carrier — Active
Active Authority
1
Revoked / Inactive
0
Authority Types
1
Insurance Policies
2 active
Latest: Apr 30, 2019
BOC-3 Filing
On file

Operating Authority

fmcsa-authhistApr 5, 2026
Operating Authority
Authority TypeDocket #StatusOriginal DateFinal Date
Common CarrierMC-645548ACTIVEUnknownMay 1, 2019

Active Insurance (2)

fmcsa-insurApr 5, 2026
Active Insurance (2)
InsurerTypePolicy #StatusEffectiveCancel Date
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryCA0657288ON FILEApr 30, 2019Jul 22, 2019
PRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANYCARGOP0032 800 504ON FILEApr 11, 2010Apr 11, 2011

Insurance History (20 canceled/expired)

fmcsa-inshist-allwithhistory
Insurance History (20 canceled/expired)
InsurerTypePolicy #StatusEffectiveCancel Date
NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO.BIPD/PrimaryCNY0004935635-8CANCELLEDMay 1, 2018Jul 10, 2018
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-02CANCELLEDApr 30, 2018Apr 30, 2019
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-02REPLACEDApr 30, 2018May 1, 2018
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-01REPLACEDApr 30, 2017Apr 30, 2018
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-00CANCELLEDApr 30, 2016Apr 30, 2017
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-00REPLACEDApr 30, 2016Apr 30, 2016
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryFLNCA022000019-00CANCELLEDApr 30, 2016Jul 11, 2016
UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO.BIPD/Primary383459REPLACEDApr 30, 2015Apr 30, 2016
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryCA 3075842REPLACEDMay 9, 2014Apr 30, 2015
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryCA 3075842CANCELLEDMay 9, 2014Jun 19, 2015
NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO.BIPD/PrimaryCNY 000 7313784-3REPLACEDApr 4, 2014May 9, 2014
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryCA 2153353CANCELLEDApr 11, 2013May 22, 2013
NOVA CASUALTY COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryTIP-CL-0011361-0CANCELLEDApr 11, 2012Apr 11, 2013
PARK INSURANCE COBIPD/Primary02PICAU1052-11REPLACEDJun 17, 2011Apr 11, 2012
PARK INSURANCE COBIPD/Primary02PICAU1052-11CANCELLEDApr 11, 2011Jun 17, 2011
PRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryP0032 800 504CANCELLEDApr 11, 2010Apr 11, 2011
REDLAND INSURANCE CO.BIPD/PrimaryR0010 710 365REPLACEDApr 11, 2009Apr 11, 2010
REDLAND INSURANCE CO.CARGOR0010 710 365REPLACEDApr 11, 2009Apr 11, 2010
REDLAND INSURANCE CO.CARGOR0010 710 220REPLACEDMay 29, 2008Apr 11, 2009
REDLAND INSURANCE CO.BIPD/PrimaryR0010 710 220REPLACEDMay 29, 2008Apr 11, 2009

Insurance Events Timeline

fmcsa-insur-hist
Insurance Events Timeline
EventInsurerPolicy #TypeEvent DateCancel Date
TERM/REPLPROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYCA0657288BIPD/PrimaryJul 22, 2019Jul 22, 2019
CANCELFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-02BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2019Apr 30, 2019
CANCELNATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO.CNY0004935635-8BIPD/PrimaryJul 10, 2018Jul 10, 2018
TERM/REPLFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-02BIPD/PrimaryMay 1, 2018May 1, 2018
TERM/REPLFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-01BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2018Apr 30, 2018
CANCELFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-00BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2017Apr 30, 2017
TERM/CANCLFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-00BIPD/PrimaryJul 11, 2016Jul 11, 2016
TERM/REPLFALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANYFLNCA022000019-00BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2016Apr 30, 2016
TERM/REPLUNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO.383459BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2016Apr 30, 2016
TERM/CANCLPROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYCA 3075842BIPD/PrimaryJun 19, 2015Jun 19, 2015
TERM/REPLPROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYCA 3075842BIPD/PrimaryApr 30, 2015Apr 30, 2015
TERM/REPLNATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO.CNY 000 7313784-3BIPD/PrimaryMay 9, 2014May 9, 2014
CANCELPROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYCA 2153353BIPD/PrimaryMay 22, 2013May 22, 2013
CANCELNOVA CASUALTY COMPANYTIP-CL-0011361-0BIPD/PrimaryApr 11, 2013Apr 11, 2013
TERM/REPLPARK INSURANCE CO02PICAU1052-11BIPD/PrimaryApr 11, 2012Apr 11, 2012
CANCELPARK INSURANCE CO02PICAU1052-11BIPD/PrimaryJun 17, 2011Jun 17, 2011
CANCELPRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANYP0032 800 504CARGOApr 11, 2011Apr 11, 2011
CANCELPRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANYP0032 800 504BIPD/PrimaryApr 11, 2011Apr 11, 2011
TERM/REPLREDLAND INSURANCE CO.R0010 710 365CARGOApr 11, 2010Apr 11, 2010
TERM/REPLREDLAND INSURANCE CO.R0010 710 365BIPD/PrimaryApr 11, 2010Apr 11, 2010
TERM/REPLREDLAND INSURANCE CO.R0010 710 220CARGOApr 11, 2009Apr 11, 2009
TERM/REPLREDLAND INSURANCE CO.R0010 710 220BIPD/PrimaryApr 11, 2009Apr 11, 2009

Authority Revocations

fmcsa-revocations
Authority Revocations
AuthorityDocketReasonDate
COMMONMC-645548INVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONUnknown
COMMONMC-645548INVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONUnknown

Authority Action History (9 events)

fmcsa-authhist-blob
Authority Action History (9 events)
DocketAuthority TypeOriginal ActionServed DateDispositionDecided Date
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONApr 3, 2019DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONMay 1, 2019
MC645548MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERREINSTATEDAug 8, 2018Unknown
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONApr 3, 2017DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONMay 1, 2017
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONMay 26, 2015DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONJun 18, 2015
MC645548MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERREINSTATEDJun 27, 2014REVOKEDJul 16, 2018
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONMar 15, 2013DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONApr 12, 2013
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONMay 23, 2011DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONMay 26, 2011
MC645548COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONMar 15, 2011DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONApr 12, 2011
MC645548MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERGRANTEDJun 6, 2008REVOKEDMay 28, 2013

Safety & Inspections

SMS BASIC scores, inspection history, and out-of-service rates

SMS BASIC Scores

Hours of Service
N/A
Unsafe Driving
48%

Higher percentile = worse safety performance relative to peers. Scores at or above 75% trigger FMCSA alerts.

Inspections
14
Violations
32
9 OOS
Vehicle OOS %
28.6%
Above nat'l avg (23.4%)
Driver OOS %
0.0%
Power Units (MCS-150)
4
Drivers (MCS-150)
4
Crash Records
6

Inspection Activity (24 months)

Monthly inspection counts with OOS months highlighted. Hover bars for details.

May
2
Jun
2
Jul
Aug
1
Sep
Oct
1
Nov
Dec
1
Jan
Feb
Mar
1
Apr
May
1
Jun
Jul
1
Aug
1
Sep
Oct
Nov
1
Dec
Jan
Feb
1
Mar
Apr
Clean monthMonth with OOSBased on latest 14 of 14 inspection records

Inspection Activity Map

1 state14 inspections

🚛
None Low Medium High🚛 Home base

Violation Summary (32 violations from 14 inspections)

fmcsa-inspection-file
Violation Summary (32 violations from 14 inspections)
CodeDescription# Violations# OOSSeverity WtBASIC
FMCSR:392.2Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued408Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:392.9A2-CCargo - Vehicle components or dunnage not secured22Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.11A1-LCHLLighting devices/reflectors203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLEQPOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued208Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.60DGlazing/window obstructions204Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45A-BLHFBrake tubing/hoses inadequate117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.41-BNPBBrake - Inoperative or missing parking brake on power unit11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLSIVOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.9A-LLPLInoperable required lamps103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95FEmergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLUCROperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:390.21TC-MC390.21TC-MC10General/Admin
FMCSR:393.128B-CLWVCargo securement - roll-on/roll-off containers116Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16-DFailing to use seat belt (49 CFR)103Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.9(a)Inoperable required lamps103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11(a)(1)Lighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.9(a)(2)Failing to secure vehicle equipment11Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.112Tiedown not adjustable by driver10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.128(b)Cargo securement - roll-on/roll-off containers116Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.209(d)Wheel fasteners loose/missing118Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.41No or defective parking brake system on CMV11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5(b)Fuel system leak107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16(a)Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)103Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:391.41(a)Physical qualification - general107Driver Fitness

Peer Context

This carrier vs national averages. Lower is better for all metrics.

Vehicle OOS Rate
28.6%vs nat'l 23.4%
+5.2 pts above avg
Driver OOS Rate
0.0%vs nat'l 6.7%
-6.7 pts below avg
Violations / Inspection
2.29vs nat'l 1.80
+0.49 above avg

National averages: vehicle OOS 23.4%, driver OOS 6.7%, violations per inspection ~1.8. Based on FMCSA MCSAP program data.

Inspection analytics

Monthly cadence, frequent stations, and violation mix

Inspections per month (24 mo)

14 total · 28.6% OOS
2024-042026-03
InspectionsOOS

Most frequent inspection stations

Violations by BASIC category

Recent Crashes

6 crash records from FMCSA Crash File

Total Crashes
6
Fatalities
0
Injuries
3
Across 3 crashes
Tow-Aways
4

Crash History (6 records)

fmcsa-crash-fileApr 5, 2026
Crash History (6 records)
DateStateSeverityFatalitiesInjuriesCityLocationVINCarrier Name at Crash
Jan 6, 2021NYTOW00Rt 211 Ref Mrkr 211 83012018...G81509COMPLETE AUTO RECOVERY SERVICES INC
Oct 25, 2019NYINJURY01
Jul 7, 2019NYTOW00
Mar 7, 2013NYINJURY01
Jul 27, 2012NYTOW00
Aug 31, 2011NYINJURY01

Compliance Timeline

29 events merged from authority, insurance, enforcement, OOS, crash, MCS-150, and safety rating records

Jan 6, 2021
Crash
Tow-away crash in NY
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
Oct 25, 2019
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Jul 22, 2019
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Jul 7, 2019
Crash
Tow-away crash
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
May 1, 2019
Authority
Apr 30, 2019
Insurance
Insurance cancel
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Jul 10, 2018
Insurance
Insurance cancel
NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO. • BIPD/Primary
May 1, 2018
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 30, 2018
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 30, 2017
Insurance
Insurance cancel
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Jul 11, 2016
Insurance
Insurance term/cancl
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 30, 2016
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
FALLS LAKE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 30, 2016
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO. • BIPD/Primary
Jun 19, 2015
Insurance
Insurance term/cancl
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 30, 2015
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
May 9, 2014
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO. • BIPD/Primary
May 22, 2013
Insurance
Insurance cancel
PROGRESSIVE CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Apr 11, 2013
Insurance
Insurance cancel
NOVA CASUALTY COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
Mar 7, 2013
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Jul 27, 2012
Crash
Tow-away crash
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
Apr 11, 2012
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
PARK INSURANCE CO • BIPD/Primary
Aug 31, 2011
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Jun 17, 2011
Insurance
Insurance cancel
PARK INSURANCE CO • BIPD/Primary
Apr 11, 2011
Insurance
Insurance cancel
PRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANY • CARGO
Apr 11, 2011
Insurance
Insurance cancel
PRAETORIAN INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary

Showing most recent 25 of 29 events

Related Records

Data sources & freshness

FMCSA Company Census File
Generated from 24-hour old database. Contact info and fleet counts may lag.
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Authority History
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Insurance Filings
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Vehicle Inspection File
Updated 1 weeks ago
Refresh dataLast updated: Apr 5, 2026