ALCIDE BUTLER

USDOT 2799076 • DBA: AL & D BUTLER • 8108 I-35W, ALVARADO, TX, 76009

ACTIVEMotor Carrier
Authority:1 active
Insurance:1 current
BOC-3:On file
Safety Rating:S
MCS-150:Never updated
OOS Orders:1 active

Overview

Company profile from FMCSA Census File

USDOT
2,799,076
Status
ACTIVE
Operation
Interstate
Business Type
Motor Carrier
State
Phone
2145359960
Power Units (MCS-150)
4
Drivers (MCS-150)
4
Safety Rating
S
MCS-150 Mileage
2,000,000
Physical Address
8108 I-35W, ALVARADO, TX, 76009
Mailing Address
2637 GARDENDALE DR., FORT WORTH, TX, 76120
Contact

Risk Signals3 flagged

HIGH
1 active Out-of-Service order
Active OOS orders prevent this carrier from operating until rescinded. See the OOS Orders table for details.
MEDIUM
Elevated vehicle OOS rate: 81.8%
National average is 23.4%. This carrier's vehicle OOS rate is 58.4 percentage points above average.
MEDIUM
Elevated driver OOS rate: 36.4%
National average is 6.7%. This carrier's driver OOS rate is 29.7 percentage points above average.

Signals are auto-detected from FMCSA public records. This is not a regulatory determination.

Authority & Insurance

Operating authority, insurance filings, and BOC-3 status

Common Carrier — Active
Active Authority
1
Revoked / Inactive
0
Authority Types
1
Insurance Policies
1 active
Latest: Nov 13, 2021
BOC-3 Filing
On file

Operating Authority

fmcsa-authhistApr 5, 2026
Operating Authority
Authority TypeDocket #StatusOriginal DateFinal Date
Common CarrierMC-939815ACTIVEUnknownDec 16, 2022

Active Insurance (1)

fmcsa-insurApr 5, 2026
Active Insurance (1)
InsurerTypePolicy #StatusEffectiveCancel Date
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALBIPD/PrimaryCA953606933ON FILENov 13, 2021Nov 13, 2022

Insurance History (6 canceled/expired)

fmcsa-inshist-allwithhistory
Insurance History (6 canceled/expired)
InsurerTypePolicy #StatusEffectiveCancel Date
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALBIPD/PrimaryCA953606933CANCELLEDNov 13, 2021Dec 19, 2022
GREAT WEST CASUALTY CO.BIPD/PrimaryMCP65243AREPLACEDNov 27, 2020Nov 13, 2020
GREAT WEST CASUALTY CO.BIPD/PrimaryMCP65243ACANCELLEDNov 13, 2020Nov 13, 2021
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALBIPD/PrimaryCA 6314724REPLACEDNov 27, 2017Nov 13, 2020
HALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryA42506931-01CANCELLEDNov 11, 2016Nov 11, 2017
HALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANYBIPD/PrimaryA42506931CANCELLEDNov 11, 2015Nov 11, 2016

Insurance Events Timeline

fmcsa-insur-hist
Insurance Events Timeline
EventInsurerPolicy #TypeEvent DateCancel Date
TERM/CANCLPROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALCA953606933BIPD/PrimaryDec 19, 2022Dec 19, 2022
TERM/REPLPROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALCA953606933BIPD/PrimaryNov 13, 2022Nov 13, 2022
CANCELGREAT WEST CASUALTY CO.MCP65243ABIPD/PrimaryNov 13, 2021Nov 13, 2021
TERM/REPLPROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUALCA 6314724BIPD/PrimaryNov 13, 2020Nov 13, 2020
TERM/REPLGREAT WEST CASUALTY CO.MCP65243ABIPD/PrimaryNov 13, 2020Nov 13, 2020
CANCELHALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANYA42506931-01BIPD/PrimaryNov 11, 2017Nov 11, 2017
CANCELHALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANYA42506931BIPD/PrimaryNov 11, 2016Nov 11, 2016

Authority Revocations

fmcsa-revocations
Authority Revocations
AuthorityDocketReasonDate
COMMONMC-939815INVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONUnknown

Authority Action History (6 events)

fmcsa-authhist-blob
Authority Action History (6 events)
DocketAuthority TypeOriginal ActionServed DateDispositionDecided Date
MC939815COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONNov 22, 2022DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONDec 16, 2022
MC939815COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONOct 18, 2021DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONNov 12, 2021
MC939815MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERGRANTEDNov 28, 2017Unknown
MC939815MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERREINSTATEDNov 28, 2017Unknown
MC939815COMMONINVOLUNTARY REVOCATIONOct 17, 2016DISCONTINUED REVOCATIONNov 14, 2016
MC939815MOTOR PROPERTY COMMON CARRIERGRANTEDNov 16, 2015REVOKEDNov 20, 2017

Out-of-Service Orders (1)

fmcsa-oos-orders
Out-of-Service Orders (1)
OOS DateReasonStatusRescinded
Sep 8, 202490 day failure to pay fineACTIVESep 12, 2024

Safety & Inspections

SMS BASIC scores, inspection history, and out-of-service rates

SMS BASIC Scores

Hours of Service
73%
Unsafe Driving
48%

Higher percentile = worse safety performance relative to peers. Scores at or above 75% trigger FMCSA alerts.

Inspections
11
Violations
96
20 OOS
Vehicle OOS %
81.8%
Above nat'l avg (23.4%)
Driver OOS %
36.4%
Above nat'l avg (6.7%)
Power Units (MCS-150)
4
Drivers (MCS-150)
4
Crash Records
2

Inspection Activity (24 months)

Monthly inspection counts with OOS months highlighted. Hover bars for details.

May
1
Jun
1
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
1
Jun
2
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
1
Nov
Dec
Jan
Feb
1
Mar
Apr
Clean monthMonth with OOSBased on latest 11 of 11 inspection records

Inspection Activity Map

4 states11 inspections

🚛
None Low Medium High🚛 Home base

Violation Summary (96 violations from 11 inspections)

fmcsa-inspection-file
Violation Summary (96 violations from 11 inspections)
CodeDescription# Violations# OOSSeverity WtBASIC
FMCSR:393.9(a)Inoperable required lamps1543Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2RGOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued1008Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:396.17CNo proof of periodic inspection803Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued508Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.11Lighting devices/reflectors403Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75CTire tread depth insufficient (other axles)315Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:395.8A-ELDFailing to keep RODS337Hours Of Service
FMCSR:393.75(c)Tire tread depth insufficient (other axles)315Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55C1Coupling device/towing methods defective208Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75A1Tire-ply or belt material exposed21Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9TInoperable tail lamp20Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9TSInoperative turn signal20Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1Inspection repair and maintenance of parts and accessories20Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95AEmergency equipment - fire extinguisher missing/defective205Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5B-HLOWFuel system leak207Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5B-HWSLOWFuel system leak207Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11TLLighting devices/reflectors203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55D3Coupling device/towing methods defective108Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1DSDTDrive Shaft Tube Cracked or Twisted11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5BFuel system leak107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.60AUnauthorized passenger on board CMV10Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:390.21(a)Vehicle marking requirements103General/Admin
FMCSR:393.24DLighting/marking on projecting loads103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45D-SGNCNBBrake tubing/hoses inadequate107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:395.8A-NON-ELDFailing to keep RODS117Hours Of Service
FMCSR:395.8K2Driver failing to retain previous 7 days records of duty status10Hours Of Service
FMCSR:396.3A1BOSBRAKES OUT OF SERVICE: The number of defective brakes is equal to or greater than 20 percent of the service brakes on the vehicle or combination11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45UVBrake tubing/hoses inadequate117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48AInoperative/defective brakes108Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9Inoperable Required Lamp10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95FEmergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:395.8Record of Duty Status violation (general/form and manner)10Hours Of Service
FMCSR:392.2-SLLS3Speeding 11-14 mph over limit107Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.42A-BMBrakes - parking brake defective116Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11(a)(1)Lighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:387.303(b)(4)387.303(b)(4)10General/Admin
FMCSR:396.17(c)No proof of periodic inspection103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:391.41(a)Physical qualification - general107Driver Fitness
FMCSR:393.75(a)Tires/tubes - general defects116Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45(b)(2)Brake tubing/hoses inadequate117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.205(c)Wheel fasteners loose and/or missing11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75(a)(1)Tire-ply or belt material exposed11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.78Windshield condition defective104Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5(b)Fuel system leak117Vehicle Maintenance

Peer Context

This carrier vs national averages. Lower is better for all metrics.

Vehicle OOS Rate
81.8%vs nat'l 23.4%
+58.4 pts above avg
Driver OOS Rate
36.4%vs nat'l 6.7%
+29.7 pts above avg
Violations / Inspection
8.73vs nat'l 1.80
+6.93 above avg

National averages: vehicle OOS 23.4%, driver OOS 6.7%, violations per inspection ~1.8. Based on FMCSA MCSAP program data.

Inspection analytics

Monthly cadence, frequent stations, and violation mix

Inspections per month (24 mo)

7 total · 100.0% OOS
2024-062026-03
InspectionsOOS

Most frequent inspection stations

Violations by BASIC category

Recent Crashes

2 crash records from FMCSA Crash File

Total Crashes
2
Fatalities
0
Injuries
1
Across 1 crash
Tow-Aways
2

Crash History (2 records)

fmcsa-crash-fileApr 5, 2026
Crash History (2 records)
DateStateSeverityFatalitiesInjuriesCityLocationVINCarrier Name at Crash
Nov 3, 2020LATOW00
May 31, 2017OKINJURY01

Enforcement Actions

1 closed case — FMCSA civil penalties

1 Enforcement Case

fmcsa-enforcement
1 Enforcement Case
Case NumberClosed DateViolation Code(s)SettlementSubject Type
TX-2023-1239-US1217Nov 15, 2023396.3(a)$4,420Carrier

Compliance Timeline

13 events merged from authority, insurance, enforcement, OOS, crash, MCS-150, and safety rating records

Sep 12, 2024
OOS
OOS order rescinded
90 day failure to pay fine
Sep 8, 2024
OOS
OOS order issued
90 day failure to pay fine
Nov 15, 2023
Enforcement
Enforcement case closed • $4,420
Case TX-2023-1239-US1217 • 396.3(a)
Dec 19, 2022
Insurance
Insurance term/cancl
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUAL • BIPD/Primary
Dec 16, 2022
Authority
Nov 13, 2022
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUAL • BIPD/Primary
Nov 13, 2021
Insurance
Insurance cancel
GREAT WEST CASUALTY CO. • BIPD/Primary
Nov 13, 2020
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUAL • BIPD/Primary
Nov 13, 2020
Insurance
Insurance term/repl
GREAT WEST CASUALTY CO. • BIPD/Primary
Nov 3, 2020
Crash
Tow-away crash
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
Nov 11, 2017
Insurance
Insurance cancel
HALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary
May 31, 2017
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Nov 11, 2016
Insurance
Insurance cancel
HALLMARK COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY • BIPD/Primary

Related Records

Data sources & freshness

FMCSA Company Census File
Generated from 24-hour old database. Contact info and fleet counts may lag.
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Authority History
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Insurance Filings
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Vehicle Inspection File
Updated 1 weeks ago
Refresh dataLast updated: Apr 5, 2026