BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC

Joins 27 roadside inspections (24 mo) from FMCSA public filings. Data as of Oct 28, 2026. Booking triage is above; confirm on SAFER before tendering.

Brokers & shippers · booking check

Book with caution — review signals below

No hard OOS / revoked / uninsured blocker, but elevated risk signals need a human look before booking.

Caution

Review these

OOS rate worse than size peers Driver 2.80% vs peer 0.00% · Vehicle 50.0% vs peer 14.3% Details →

Built for brokers and shippers deciding whether to tender. Always confirm on FMCSA SAFER and L&I before booking — TruckCodex mirrors public filings and can lag by up to a day. Open full book-check tool

Plain-text risk summary (print / paste)

TruckCodex risk summary — BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC (USDOT 2383079)
Verdict: CAUTION
Book with caution — review signals below
No hard OOS / revoked / uninsured blocker, but elevated risk signals need a human look before booking.

Authority / census status: Active

Blockers:
  (none)

Cautions:
  • OOS rate worse than size peers — Driver 2.80% vs peer 0.00% · Vehicle 50.0% vs peer 14.3%

On file:
  (none)

Source: https://truckcodex.com/usdot/2383079/
As of: Oct 28, 2026
Always confirm on FMCSA SAFER and L&I before tendering — TruckCodex mirrors public filings and can lag by up to a day.

USDOT 2383079 Active PRIVATE PROPERTY Company officer: TODD BUTLER Garbage / Refuse Based in PHOENIX, NY

FMCSA census as of Oct 28, 2026 · Sources · Freshness · Methodology · Disclaimer

TruckCodex · filing & peer scorecard

TruckCodex filing & peer scorecard · B

Composite of 3/5 scored components (mean 72/100). Separate from booking triage on this page. Expand for per-signal evidence. Heuristic — not an FMCSA rating or legal advice.

B confidence 60% · 3/5 signals · expand

Authority / census

Active · 100/100

Active census status with no OOS order or revoked authority on file.

Insurance / BIPD

Insurance/BIPD signal not resolved for this carrier.

NR reason: No active policies and no uninsured flag to score against.

OOS vs peers

Riskier than peers · 15/100

Driver OOS 2.8% vs peer median 0% (worse). Vehicle OOS 50% vs peer median 14.3% (worse). n=25377 same-size ACTIVE peers.

FMCSA safety rating

Unrated

FMCSA has not assigned this carrier a formal safety rating. We do not invent one.

NR reason: No published FMCSA safety_rating.

Insurance-watch tier

Not on watch · 100/100

No BMC-91 insurance-lapse watch classification on file for this USDOT.

TruckCodex filing & peer scorecard from authority, BIPD, peer OOS, FMCSA safety rating, and insurance-watch signals. Not a booking verdict and not legal advice. See methodology. Booking triage on this page: Caution.

Field change history →

Operating authority

No authority breakdown on file.

Insurance

No active policies on file.

BOC-3 agent

No BOC-3 filing on file.

Company profile

Company details

USDOT 2383079

In FMCSA records since Mar 1, 2013 (~13y)

Company officer TODD BUTLER

Operation PRIVATE PROPERTY

Cargo carried

Garbage / Refuse

Fleet size 40 units

Drivers 30

Annual mileage 1,550,000 mi

Contact & address

Phone: (315) 342-0832

Email: [email protected]

Physical

24 HOAG DR

PHOENIX, NY 13135

Mailing

P O BOX 728

FULTON, NY 13069

Registration & safety rating

USDOT 2383079

In FMCSA records since Mar 1, 2013 (~13y)

Operation PRIVATE PROPERTY

Annual mileage (MCS-150) 1,550,000 mi

vs. National Average

Vehicle OOS Rate 50.0% vs 23.4% +26.6 pts

Driver OOS Rate 2.8% vs 6.7% -3.9 pts

Violations per Inspection 4.04 vs 1.80 +2.24

Peer tier (mid-sized fleets (11-100 power units)) median OOS rate: 27.7%

FMCSA cargo filing (BMC-34/83)

No active FMCSA cargo filing on file.

FMCSA L&I filing evidence — not a shipper certificate of insurance (COI). Cargo (BMC-34) is primarily an HHG / household-goods requirement; general freight carriers often have none.

Broker bond / trust (BMC-84/85)

No active broker surety bond or trust fund on file.

BMC-84 is a surety bond; BMC-85 is a trust-fund agreement. Required for property brokers / freight forwarders — not motor-carrier BIPD liability insurance.

Fleet details (MCS-150)

Vehicle type	Owned	Term leased	Trip leased
Trucks	40	0	0

Self-reported on the carrier’s Form MCS-150 (FMCSA Company Census).

Accident reports (24 months)

All 9 crashes →

	12–24 months	Total
Fatalities	0	0
Injuries	2	2
Tow-away	3	3
Crash reports	3	3

Reportable crashes from FMCSA MCMIS for the trailing 24 months. Counts may differ slightly from SAFER due to reporting lag.

Inspections (24 months)

All 63 inspections →

	Driver	Vehicle	Hazmat
Inspections	27	27	0
OOS inspections	1	9	0
OOS percentage	3.7%	33.33%	—
National average	6.7%	23.4%	4.4%

Roadside inspections in the last 24 months. National averages are FMCSA MCSAP reference rates (driver ~6.7%, vehicle ~23.4%, hazmat ~4.4%).

Power Units

Drivers

Inspections

FMCSA roadside history on file

OOS Rate (peak)

50.0%

driver or vehicle, whichever higher

Crashes (24m)

9 all-time

Authorities

Risk Signals

High OOS rate

Peak OOS rate of 50.0% is well above FMCSA MCSAP national averages (driver ~6.7%, vehicle ~23.4%).

Out-of-Service rate vs same-size peers FMCSA roadside inspections, % placed out-of-service

Compared against 25,377 ACTIVE carriers operating 20–60 power units (±50% of this carrier's 40 unit fleet).

This carrier — Driver OOS

2.8%

Drivers placed out-of-service at roadside inspections

Peer median

Median across 25,377 same-size peers

Verdict

Riskier than peers

Delta +2.8 pts vs peer median (lower is safer)

This carrier — Vehicle OOS

50%

Vehicles placed out-of-service at roadside inspections

Peer median

14.3%

Median across 25,377 same-size peers

Verdict

Riskier than peers

Delta +35.7 pts vs peer median (lower is safer)

Inspection Analytics Monthly activity · BASIC mix · state map

Monthly Inspection Activity (25 months)

2023-11 2026-09

Violations by BASIC Category

Federal BASIC buckets for every citation issued against this carrier over the past 24 months.

Controlled Substances/Alcohol

1 violation

1 OOS · 100.0%

Activity by State

States this carrier has been inspected in over the past 24 months.

State	Inspections	OOS	OOS %	Last Inspection
New York (NY)	27	9	33.3%	Sep 29, 2026

Vehicle Fleet Top makes and models observed in roadside inspections

Make	Model	Inspections
Mack		47
Hino		3
Peterbilt		3
Mack Truck		1

SMS BASIC Scores FMCSA Safety Measurement System per-BASIC scores

BASIC	Inspections	Serious	Measure	Percentile	Alert	As Of
Driver Fitness	1	—	0.84	1	—	Oct 26, 2026
Controlled Substances / Alcohol	1	—	0.06	0	—	Oct 26, 2026
Hours of Service	0	—	0.00	0	—	Oct 26, 2026
Unsafe Driving	6	—	0.95	1	—	Oct 26, 2026
Vehicle Maintenance	20	—	18.63	19	—	Oct 26, 2026

Higher percentiles indicate worse performance relative to peer carriers. Carriers at or above the FMCSA intervention threshold are marked ALERT.

Recent Inspections (63 rows) View all 63 →

Inspection #	Date ▼	State	Level	Station	Vehicle	Violations	Top Codes	OOS
89134937	Sep 29, 2026	NY	2	EAST SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 91816NE · 1M2GR2GC0SM045429	1	393.207A-SAPPAS	Yes
87297633	Mar 9, 2026	NY	2	SANDY CREEK NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 68655NB · 1M2LR1GC1NM005244	5	396.5B-L, 393.9A-LHLI, 393.95F	No
87055155	Feb 10, 2026	NY	2	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 65972NE · 1M2GR2GC3RM043006	1	393.95A1	No
87013195	Feb 4, 2026	NY	2	PULASKI NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 74614NC · 1M2TE2GC0NM006886	5	393.75A3-TAOL, 393.9A-HLLH, 393.11A1-LLPL	Yes
86734877	Jan 5, 2026	NY	1	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20443MD · 1M2GR4GC6LM014926	22	396.3A1-BOS, 393.205A-WRDC, 396.3A1-TAOCV	Yes
86659726	Dec 22, 2025	NY	2	OSWEGO NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 42341MK · 1M2AV02C9JM019018	11	393.9A-LSML, 393.9A-LIL, 393.95F	No
86564650	Dec 8, 2025	NY	2	FULTON NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 78651ND · 1M2LR1GC2PM007622	5	393.205C-WR, 393.205A-WRBH, 393.9A-LTSI	Yes
86309423	Nov 13, 2025	NY	2	PHOENIX NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20447MD · 1M2AU04C2EM008299	6	393.9A-LCL, 393.9A-LBL, 393.95F	No
85923002	Sep 24, 2025	NY	3	DEWITT NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 14885NG · 1M2LR2GC2SM010227	0	—	No
85901328	Sep 22, 2025	NY	3	SYRACUSE NY	PETERBILT STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 77036ND · 2NP8LJ0X0PM875114	2	392.2-SLLIFTA, 392.2-SLLSR	No
85873715	Sep 18, 2025	NY	3	SYRACUSE NY	HINO STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20431MD · 5PVNV8JV8H4S57198	1	392.2-SLLSR	No
85758349	Sep 11, 2025	NY	1	FULTON NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 50601MK · 1M2AU04CXGM010417	9	393.9A-LTSI, 396.3A1-BOS, 393.48A-BMBCBD	Yes
85122283	Jul 2, 2025	NY	3	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 50602MK · 1M2AU04C1GM010418	1	392.2-SLLFC	No
85098007	Jun 24, 2025	NY	3	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 91816NE · 1M2GR2GC0SM045429	3	392.2-SLLSR, 392.2-SLLIFTA	No
84548948	Apr 24, 2025	NY	2	JAMESVILLE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20443MD · 1M2GR4GC6LM014926	1	393.9A-HLLH	No
84527903	Apr 22, 2025	NY	1	OSWEGO NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20453MD · 1M2LR1GC7LM003057	13	393.48A-BI-SA, 393.47D1-BLTBD-SA, 393.47B-BMBCBD-SA	Yes
84075083	Mar 3, 2025	NY	2	FULTON NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 37606ML · 1M2GR2GC9KM001557	2	393.134B-CRHLC, 393.86B1-RIG	Yes
83965432	Feb 24, 2025	NY	2	PHOENIX NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 50601MK · 1M2AU04CXGM010417	10	392.5A3-IDUI, 393.9A-LTSI, 393.9A-LFTSI	Yes
83834934	Feb 4, 2025	NY	3	CICERO NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 42341MK · 1M2AV02C9JM019018	1	392.16-D	No
83761218	Jan 27, 2025	NY	3	DEWITT NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20443MD · 1M2GR4GC6LM014926	1	392.2-SLLSR	No
83724024	Jan 23, 2025	NY	2	DEWITT NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20443MD · 1M2GR4GC6LM014926	1	393.9A-LHLI	No
83679675	Jan 22, 2025	NY	2	PHOENIX NY	HINO STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20431MD · 5PVNV8JV8H4S57198	0	—	No
83679620	Jan 22, 2025	NY	2	PHOENIX NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 37606ML · 1M2GR2GC9KM001557	3	393.75A3-TAOL, 393.9A-LRLI, 393.9A-LHLI	Yes
83586443	Jan 6, 2025	NY	2	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20443MD · 1M2GR4GC6LM014926	2	393.9A-LLPL, 393.9A-LHLI	No
83470303	Dec 17, 2024	NY	3	SYRACUSE NY	MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK NY 20448MD · 1M2TE2GC2SM012040	1	392.16-D	No

Recent Crashes (9 rows)

Report #	Date ▼	State	Injuries	Tow	Hazmat	Severity
NY4090953400	Aug 7, 2025	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NY4083611800	Jun 9, 2025	NY	0	Yes	No	Tow
NY4082800800	Jun 2, 2025	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NYSP44204930	Apr 22, 2022	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NY3822893500	Dec 11, 2019	NY	0	Yes	No	Tow
NY3773258300	Feb 6, 2019	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NYSP32625610	Oct 19, 2018	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NYSP29936080	Jan 3, 2018	NY	1	Yes	No	Injury
NYSP29148890	Oct 27, 2017	NY	0	Yes	No	Tow

Top Stations & Violation Codes Where this carrier gets inspected and what they get cited for

Most-Inspected Stations

Station	State	Inspections	OOS
SYRACUSE NY	NY	9	1
DEWITT	NY	8	0
FULTON NY	NY	5	5
PHOENIX NY	NY	4	2
DEWITT NY	NY	3	0
OSWEGO NY	NY	3	2
SYRACUSE	NY	3	0
481 DEWITT	NY	2	0
JAMESVILLE NY	NY	2	0
ONONDAGA	NY	2	0

Top Violation Codes Cited

Code	Description	Category	Cited	OOS
393.9(a)	Inoperable required lamps	Vehicle Maintenance	43	2
392.2	Violation of Local Laws	Unsafe Driving	17	0
393.47(e)	Brake Out of Adjustment - Roto, Clamp (Short & Long), DD-3, or Bolt	Vehicle Maintenance	17	0
396.3(a)(1)	Inspection, repair and maintenance of parts and accessories	Vehicle Maintenance	11	5
393.78	Wipers - Inoperative / missing / damaged wipers.	Vehicle Maintenance	8	0
392.16(a)	Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)	Unsafe Driving	7	0
393.11	No or defective lighting devices or reflective material as required	Vehicle Maintenance	4	0
393.45(b)(2)	Brake hose or tubing chafing and/or kinking	Vehicle Maintenance	4	1
393.48(a)	Inoperative/defective brakes	Vehicle Maintenance	4	0
393.53(b)	CMV manufactured after 10/19/94 has an automatic airbrake adjustment system that fails to compensate for wear	Vehicle Maintenance	4	0

Booking & risk tools

Open dedicated checkers pre-filled with this USDOT — same public filings as the triage card above.

Book / don't book Insurance check Cancel desk Chameleon check Safety benchmark

Related Records

New York carriers Phoenix carriers 63 inspections 9 reportable crashes Book / don't book Insurance check Cancel desk

All cross-references Authority, BOC-3, risk tools, explainers, and more

Field change history

Field change history
History-watch change dates and as-of snapshots