BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC

USDOT 2383079 • 24 HOAG DR, PHOENIX, NY, 13135

ACTIVE
Authority:None on file
Insurance:None on file
BOC-3:Not on file
Safety Rating:Not rated
MCS-150:Never updated
OOS Orders:None

Overview

Company profile from FMCSA Census File

USDOT
2,383,079
Status
ACTIVE
Operation
Intrastate (Non-Hazmat)
Phone
3153420832
Power Units (MCS-150)
40
Drivers (MCS-150)
30
MCS-150 Mileage
1,550,000
Physical Address
24 HOAG DR, PHOENIX, NY, 13135
Mailing Address
P O BOX 728, FULTON, NY, 13069
Contact

Risk Signals1 flagged

MEDIUM
Elevated vehicle OOS rate: 35.5%
National average is 23.4%. This carrier's vehicle OOS rate is 12.1 percentage points above average.

Signals are auto-detected from FMCSA public records. This is not a regulatory determination.

Authority & Insurance

Operating authority, insurance filings, and BOC-3 status

Active Authority
0
Revoked / Inactive
0
Authority Types
0
Insurance Policies
None on file
BOC-3 Filing
Not on file

Operating Authority

fmcsa-authhistApr 5, 2026
No records found

No insurance filings found for this carrier in FMCSA records.

Check FMCSA SAFER for current insurance status

Safety & Inspections

SMS BASIC scores, inspection history, and out-of-service rates

SMS BASIC Scores

Driver Fitness
N/A
Drugs / Alcohol
0%
Hours of Service
N/A
Unsafe Driving
18%
Vehicle Maintenance
18%

Higher percentile = worse safety performance relative to peers. Scores at or above 75% trigger FMCSA alerts.

Inspections
62
Violations
320
52 OOS
Vehicle OOS %
35.5%
Above nat'l avg (23.4%)
Driver OOS %
3.2%
Power Units (MCS-150)
40
Drivers (MCS-150)
30
Crash Records
9

Inspection Activity (24 months)

Monthly inspection counts with OOS months highlighted. Hover bars for details.

2
May
2
Jun
Jul
2
Aug
2
Sep
1
Oct
1
Nov
2
Dec
5
Jan
2
Feb
1
Mar
2
Apr
May
1
Jun
1
Jul
Aug
4
Sep
Oct
1
Nov
2
Dec
1
Jan
2
Feb
1
Mar
Apr
Clean monthMonth with OOSBased on latest 62 of 62 inspection records

Inspection Activity Map

1 state62 inspections

🚛
None Low Medium High🚛 Home base

Violation Summary (320 violations from 62 inspections)

fmcsa-inspection-file
Violation Summary (320 violations from 62 inspections)
CodeDescription# Violations# OOSSeverity WtBASIC
FMCSR:393.9(a)Inoperable required lamps4323Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2Operating a CMV while ill or fatigued1708Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.47(e)Slack adjuster defective1707Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3(a)(1)Inspection/repair/maintenance - general1155Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLSROperating a CMV while ill or fatigued808Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.78Windshield condition defective804Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LHLIInoperable required lamps703Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LSMLInoperable required lamps703Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.75A3-TAOLTires - All others leaking or inflation less than 50% of the maximum inflation pressure on tire not equipped with ATIS77Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LILInoperable required lamps703Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.53B-BSteering system components worn707Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16(a)Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)703Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.95A1Emergency Equipment - Fire Extinguishers - no fire extinguisher present or not properly rated.60Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.78A-WSWindshield condition defective604Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95FEmergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper50Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-HLLHInoperable required lamps503Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.47ESlack adjuster defective507Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1-BOSBRAKES OUT OF SERVICE: The number of defective brakes is equal to or greater than 20 percent of the service brakes on the vehicle or combination55Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LSLIInoperable required lamps403Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LLPLInoperable required lamps403Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LTSIInoperable required lamps443Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16-DFailing to use seat belt (49 CFR)403Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.55(c)(2)Coupling device/towing methods defective408Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11Lighting devices/reflectors403Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48(a)Inoperative/defective brakes408Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45(b)(2)Brake tubing/hoses inadequate417Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.53(b)Steering system components worn407Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48A-BMBCBDInoperative/defective brakes308Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LCLInoperable required lamps303Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.8-DDriver - Failed to inspect /use emergency equipment30Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:396.17(c)No proof of periodic inspection303Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.16(b)Failing to use seat belt (49 CFR)303Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.75(a)(3)Tire-flat and/or audible air leak33Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LLPLLighting devices/reflectors203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48A-BIBDInoperative/defective brakes208Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.41-BNPB-SPRBrake - Inoperative or missing power unit spring brake20Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LBLInoperable required lamps203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLIFTAOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued208Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.9A-LFTSIInoperable required lamps203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LRLIInoperable required lamps203Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:99999920Unknown
FMCSR:393.55(d)(2)Coupling device/towing methods defective208Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.207A-SAPPASSuspension defective227Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.207A-STBWSuspension defective227Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45B2-BBrake tubing/hoses inadequate207Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5(b)Fuel system leak207Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55(d)(1)Coupling device/towing methods defective208Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1-BALACBrake - Audible air leak from a brake chamber20Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.207(a)Suspension defective227Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.5B-LFuel system leak107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.80AExhaust system defective104Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55C1Coupling device/towing methods defective108Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.60CGlazing/window obstructions104Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LHLMLighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LSMLLighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1-TAOCVTires - All others in contact with a part of the vehicle11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.205A-WRDCWheel/rim defective117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LTNRVLighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95A4-EEUSEmergency Equipment - Fire Extinguishers - unsecured10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.205A-WRBHWheel/rim defective117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.205C-WRWheel/Rim - Wheel fasteners loose/missing/ineffective/broken.11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1-ALBVAir Brake - Any leak from a brake valve10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLFCOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.207A-SUBLSuspension defective117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.47B-BMBCBD-SABrake actuators/chambers defective117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.48A-BI-SAInoperative/defective brakes118Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.47D1-BLTBD-SABrake actuators/chambers defective117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.11A1-LTSMLighting devices/reflectors113Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.55C2-BCoupling device/towing methods defective108Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.207A-SAPPCBLMSuspension defective107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.205C-WRAWFLMIBWheel/Rim - Any wheel fasteners loose/missing/ineffective/broken.10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.45B2-B-AIRBrake tubing/hoses inadequate107Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.134B-CRHLCCargo securement - large boulders117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.86B1-RIGRear end protection (ICC bumper) missing/defective105Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLIRPOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:392.5A3-IDUIIntoxicating - No driver shall be on duty or operate a commercial motor vehicle while the driver possesses an intoxicating beverage regardless of its alcohol con11Controlled Substances/Alcohol
FMCSR:392.2-SLLMLOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.75C-TAOTD-LT2/32Tire tread depth insufficient (other axles)105Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLEDOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:392.2-SLLTCDOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.203A-CBPCab/body components defective104Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.81-HHorn inoperable102Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.2-SLLSIVOperating a CMV while ill or fatigued108Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.11A1-LCLLighting devices/reflectors103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.95(f)Emergency Equipment - Stopped vehicle warning devices missing or improper10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.100(b)Cargo securement - aggregate working load116Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:396.3A1-ALATRAir Brake - Any leak from an air tank reservoir.10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.9A2-CCargo - Vehicle components or dunnage not secured11Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:390.3EDriver prohibited from performing safety sensitive functions per 382.501(a) in the Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse11General/Admin
FMCSR:393.201A-FRCLSFrame - cracked/loose/broken108Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.134Cargo securement - large boulders117Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.9A-LSLIWRInoperable required lamps113Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.203B-CBPCab and Body Parts - Cab/body mounts loose/broken/missing10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:390.21T(b)390.21T(b)10General/Admin
FMCSR:392.82(a)(1)Texting while driving1010Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:390.21(c)390.21(c)10General/Admin
FMCSR:390.21(b)USDOT number not displayed103General/Admin
FMCSR:393.25(f)Lamps on rear of CMV obscured by load103Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.41No or defective parking brake system on CMV10Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.51Steering wheel free play excessive106Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:392.8Failing to inspect/use emergency equipment10Unsafe Driving
FMCSR:393.207(c)Leaf spring assembly defective/missing11Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.86(a)(1)Rear end protection (ICC bumper) missing/defective105Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.87(a)Warning flags on projecting loads missing113Vehicle Maintenance
FMCSR:393.134(b)(3)Cargo securement - large boulders117Vehicle Maintenance

Peer Context

This carrier vs national averages. Lower is better for all metrics.

Vehicle OOS Rate
35.5%vs nat'l 23.4%
+12.1 pts above avg
Driver OOS Rate
3.2%vs nat'l 6.7%
-3.5 pts below avg
Violations / Inspection
5.16vs nat'l 1.80
+3.36 above avg

National averages: vehicle OOS 23.4%, driver OOS 6.7%, violations per inspection ~1.8. Based on FMCSA MCSAP program data.

Inspection History (62 inspections)

Showing 50 of 62

fmcsa-inspectionsApr 5, 2026
Inspection History (62 inspections)
DateReport #StationStateLevelVehicleViolationsTop CodesOOS
Mar 9, 202687297633SANDY CREEK NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK5393.95A1, 393.9A-LHLI, 393.9A-LSLINo
Feb 10, 202687055155SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1393.95A1No
Feb 4, 202687013195PULASKI NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK5393.11A1-LLPL, 393.9A-LSML, 393.75A3-TAOLYes
Jan 5, 202686734877SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK22393.48A-BIBD, 393.47E, 393.41-BNPB-SPRYes
Dec 22, 202586659726OSWEGO NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK11393.9A-LSML, 393.9A-LIL, 393.95FNo
Dec 8, 202586564650FULTON NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK5393.9A-LTSI, 393.205A-WRBH, 393.9A-LSLIYes
Nov 13, 202586309423PHOENIX NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK6393.95A1, 393.95F, 392.8-DNo
Sep 24, 202585923002DEWITT NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK0No
Sep 22, 202585901328SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 3PETERBILT STRAIGHT TRUCK2392.2-SLLIFTA, 392.2-SLLSRNo
Sep 18, 202585873715SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 3HINO STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2-SLLSRNo
Sep 11, 202585758349FULTON NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK9393.48A-BMBCBD, 393.11A1-LLPL, 393.53B-BYes
Jul 2, 202585122283SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2-SLLFCNo
Jun 24, 202585098007SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3392.2-SLLSR, 392.2-SLLIFTANo
Apr 24, 202584548948JAMESVILLE NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1393.9A-HLLHNo
Apr 22, 202584527903OSWEGO NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK13393.53B-B, 393.207A-SUBL, 393.47B-BMBCBD-SAYes
Mar 3, 202584075083FULTON NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2393.134B-CRHLC, 393.86B1-RIGYes
Feb 24, 202583965432PHOENIX NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK10392.16-D, 392.2-SLLIRP, 393.9A-HLLHYes
Feb 4, 202583834934CICERO NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.16-DNo
Jan 27, 202583761218DEWITT NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2-SLLSRNo
Jan 23, 202583724024DEWITT NYNYLevel 2MACK TRUCK STRAIGHT TRUCK1393.9A-LHLINo
Jan 22, 202583679620PHOENIX NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3393.75A3-TAOL, 393.9A-LHLI, 393.9A-LRLIYes
Jan 22, 202583679675PHOENIX NYNYLevel 2HINO STRAIGHT TRUCK0No
Jan 6, 202583586443SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2393.9A-LLPL, 393.9A-LHLINo
Dec 17, 202483470303SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.16-DNo
Dec 10, 202483410812JAMESVILLE NYNYLevel 3PETERBILT STRAIGHT TRUCK2392.2-SLLSR, 392.2-SLLMLNo
Nov 25, 202483283679LIVERPOOL NYNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.16-DNo
Oct 10, 202482925945PARISH NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3393.78A-WS, 393.75A3-TAOL, 393.75C-TAOTD-LT2/32Yes
Sep 12, 202482653503481 DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.16(a)No
Sep 10, 202482637397SYRACUSE NYNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK11392.8-D, 392.2-SLLED, 393.9A-LBLNo
Aug 14, 202482392316SYRACUSENYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3392.2, 393.78, 393.9(a)No
Aug 5, 202482313258481 DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2392.16(a), 396.17(c)No
Jun 13, 202481875736ONONDAGANYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2No
Jun 10, 202481825998ONONDAGANYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2No
May 24, 202481719760DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2392.2, 999No
May 20, 202481670542DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3392.16(a), 392.16(b), 999No
Mar 21, 202481173060481 CICERONYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2396.17(c), 392.2No
Mar 21, 202481173167DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2No
Feb 12, 202480835249RoadsideNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK6393.9(a), 393.55(d)(2), 393.78No
Feb 5, 202480776959CICERONYLevel 3PTRB STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2No
Jan 16, 202480652420OSWEGO NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK13393.47(e), 393.55(c)(2), 396.3A1-BOSYes
Jan 5, 202480556842DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK1392.2No
Dec 21, 202380457270HASTINGS (SB)NYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK10393.9(a), 393.75(a)(3), 396.5(b)Yes
Dec 21, 202380457340RoadsideNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK26393.9(a), 393.45(b)(2), 393.11Yes
Dec 21, 202380457232VOLNEYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK10396.3(a)(1), 393.47(e), 393.9(a)Yes
Dec 20, 202380467133DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3392.16(a), 392.16(b), 392.2No
Dec 13, 202380385849FULTON NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK9393.47(e), 393.53B-B, 396.3A1-ALATRYes
Dec 13, 202380385891FULTON NYNYLevel 1MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK13396.3A1-BALAC, 390.3E, 393.9A-LILYes
Dec 8, 202380353158DEWITTNYLevel 3MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK3392.16(a), 392.16(b), 392.2No
Dec 8, 202380353213RoadsideNYLevel 2HINO STRAIGHT TRUCK2393.9(a), 393.55(d)(2)No
Dec 8, 202380353212SR 3 VOLNEY FIRE DEPTNYLevel 2MACK STRAIGHT TRUCK2393.9(a), 393.134Yes

Inspection analytics

Monthly cadence, frequent stations, and violation mix

Inspections per month (24 mo)

35 total · 25.7% OOS
2024-052026-03
InspectionsOOS

Most frequent inspection stations

Violations by BASIC category

Vehicle Maintenance260 · 49 OOS
Unsafe Driving53 · 1 OOS
General/Admin4 · 1 OOS
Unknown2

Recent Crashes

9 crash records from FMCSA Crash File

Total Crashes
9
Fatalities
0
Injuries
6
Across 6 crashes
Tow-Aways
9

Crash History (9 records)

fmcsa-crash-fileApr 5, 2026
Crash History (9 records)
DateStateSeverityFatalitiesInjuriesCityLocationVINCarrier Name at Crash
Aug 7, 2025NYINJURY01DE WITTRef Marker:...005254BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC
Jun 9, 2025NYTOW00ONONDAGARef Marker:414 64012024...009741BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC
Jun 2, 2025NYINJURY01Ref Marker:...001557BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC
Apr 22, 2022NYINJURY01Ref Marker:...002294BUTLER DISPOSAL SYSTEMS INC
Dec 11, 2019NYTOW00
Feb 6, 2019NYINJURY01
Oct 19, 2018NYINJURY01
Jan 3, 2018NYINJURY01
Oct 27, 2017NYTOW00

Compliance Timeline

9 events merged from authority, insurance, enforcement, OOS, crash, MCS-150, and safety rating records

Aug 7, 2025
Crash
Injury crash in NY
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Jun 9, 2025
Crash
Tow-away crash in NY
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
Jun 2, 2025
Crash
Injury crash in NY
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Apr 22, 2022
Crash
Injury crash in NY
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Dec 11, 2019
Crash
Tow-away crash
0 fatalities, 0 injuries
Feb 6, 2019
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Oct 19, 2018
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Jan 3, 2018
Crash
Injury crash
0 fatalities, 1 injury
Oct 27, 2017
Crash
Tow-away crash
0 fatalities, 0 injuries

Related Records

Data sources & freshness

FMCSA Company Census File
Generated from 24-hour old database. Contact info and fleet counts may lag.
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Authority History
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Insurance Filings
Updated 1 weeks ago
FMCSA Vehicle Inspection File
Updated 1 weeks ago
Refresh dataLast updated: Apr 5, 2026