Crash Record NY3833071400
FMCSA crash record in New York on Feb 7, 2020.
Tow-Away
What happened
On February 7, 2020, FMCSA recorded a tow-away crash with no reported injuries in New York. The vehicle was operated by BIRNIE BUS SERVICE INC (USDOT 1626908). FMCSA reference NY3833071400.
Carrier pattern note
This is the carrier's 27 crashes in the past 24 months — above the typical pattern (median 0) for fleets of 51–500 power units.
Fatalities
0
Injuries
0
Vehicles
—
Carrier
BIRNIE BUS SERVICE INC
Vehicle Type
—
Severity
Tow-Away
This carrier's crash pattern
Derived from the carrier's full crash history.
Carrier crashes (24 mo)
27
16 injury · 25 tow-away
Crashes per 100 power units (24 mo)
0.6
2 crashes · 340 units
Days since prior carrier crash
59
Last on Dec 10, 2019
Vs fleet-size peers
above the median
Cohort median 0.0 · 27,029 carriers
Geographic context
How this crash sits in its setting.
Within New York, 5,817 other commercial vehicle crashes have been recorded in the past 24 months.
Agencies most active in this area:
- NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT · 336 reports
- FDNY · 36 reports
- UNKNOWN · 34 reports
Crash details
Key facts from the FMCSA crash record.
- Report #:
- NY3833071400
- Date:
- Feb 7, 2020
- Time:
- 1455
- State:
- New York
- Fatalities:
- 0
- Injuries:
- 0
- Tow-Away:
- Yes
- HazMat:
- No
- Carrier (USDOT):
- BIRNIE BUS SERVICE INC (1626908)
Other crashes by this carrier
10 additional crash record(s) on file.
| Record | Date | State | Severity | Fatalities | Injuries |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| cr_5043413 | Sep 30, 2025 | NY | Injury | 0 | 2 |
| cr_4880537 | Jan 13, 2025 | NY | Tow-Away | 0 | 0 |
| cr_4731584 | Apr 5, 2024 | NY | Tow-Away | 0 | 0 |
| cr_4864122 | Nov 9, 2023 | NY | Injury | 0 | 1 |
| cr_4555574 | May 10, 2023 | NY | Injury | 0 | 1 |
| cr_4331171 | Mar 28, 2022 | NY | Injury | 0 | 2 |
| cr_4330333 | Feb 15, 2022 | NY | Tow-Away | 0 | 0 |
| cr_4326964 | Feb 3, 2022 | NY | Tow-Away | 0 | 0 |
| cr_4281908 | Jan 7, 2022 | NY | Injury | 0 | 1 |
| cr_4243480 | Oct 18, 2021 | NY | Injury | 0 | 1 |
Carrier booking & risk tools
Check booking and risk signals for USDOT 1626908 — tools open pre-filled.
Related records
Carrier
BIRNIE BUS SERVICE INC
USDOT 1626908 · 137 crashes · 27 inspections
Safety
Carrier inspections
Roadside inspection history for this USDOT.
State
Crashes in New York
Statewide crash records.
Index
All Crash Records
Browse FMCSA commercial vehicle crash records.
Database
Roadside Inspections
Inspection history and violation details.
Database
NHTSA Recalls
Active recall campaigns.
Frequently asked questions about FMCSA crash records
What does this crash report tell me about the carrier? ▾
An individual FMCSA crash record tells you that a commercial vehicle operated by this carrier was involved in a reportable crash on the date listed, along with the severity (fatalities / injuries / tow-away) and the responding agency. A single crash record does not tell you whether the carrier was at fault, whether the driver was cited, or how the crash affected the carrier's safety scores. To evaluate the carrier, compare the full multi-year crash history against the carrier's fleet size, miles driven, and cohort peers.
Was this crash the carrier's fault? ▾
FMCSA crash records do not assign fault. Fault attribution requires reviewing the police report, any litigation outcome, and FMCSA's preventability determination if one was requested. If you need a fault determination, request the underlying state police crash report (PAR) — the carrier or its insurer can pull this through standard channels.
How does this crash affect the carrier's safety scores? ▾
Crash records feed FMCSA's Crash Indicator BASIC inside the Safety Measurement System (SMS). Each FMCSA-reportable crash counts for two years from the crash date and is weighted by severity (fatal / injury / tow-only). The Crash Indicator score is normalized against the carrier's power-unit count and exposure, so larger fleets need more crashes to score the same percentile as smaller ones. Non-reportable crashes do not enter the score.
Will this crash show up on the carrier's CSA SMS scores? ▾
If the federal_recordable flag on this record is true, yes — it will appear in the carrier's Crash Indicator BASIC for two years from the crash date. Crashes flagged state-only (state_recordable) are visible on the public crash file but do not enter the federal score.
How do I check the carrier's full crash history? ▾
Click through to the carrier profile (the USDOT link near the top of this page). The carrier's profile lists every crash on file, severity counts, and links into the SMS detail when an MC docket is on record. You can also visit FMCSA's SAFER and SMS portals directly using the carrier's USDOT number.
What if details look wrong — how do I correct an FMCSA crash record? ▾
FMCSA's DataQs system handles corrections to crash records. Either the carrier or an interested third party can file a Request for Data Review (RDR) with supporting documentation (police report, court records, witness statements). Corrections are processed by the originating state agency and propagate to the federal file within roughly 60–120 days when accepted.