Roadside Inspection 79649484

Roadside inspection on Sep 12, 2023 in New York • Carrier: WINTERS BROS HAULING OF LONG ISLAND LLC (USDOT 2483208) • Vehicle: FREIGHTLINER STRAIGHT TRUCK

Vehicle: OK Driver OOS CVSA L3
Units Inspected
1
Total Violations
2
OOS Violations
1
50% of violations
Inspection Level
Level 3

Inspection Details

Key facts from the FMCSA inspection record.

Inspection #:
79649484
Date:
Sep 12, 2023
State:
New York
Type:
Units inspected:
1
Violations:
2
HazMat:
No
Inspection site:
MELVILLE
Vehicle:
FREIGHTLINER M2 STRAIGHT TRUCK
Plate:
58287MK (NY)

What this inspection means

The driver was placed out of service at this inspection.

Cited issues fall mainly under Driver Fitness and Vehicle Maintenance, with a combined severity weight of 12.

Compared to the median Level 3 inspection nationwide in 2023, this is a more severe than typical result.

Severity context

How mild, normal, or severe was this inspection compared to its carrier, state, and station?

vs this carrier's typical
2
On par with carrier average
Carrier averages 2.13 violations per inspection across 16 prior records
vs Level 3 median in New York
2
Heavier than median (0)
Median of 24,047 Level 3 inspections in New York during 2023
vs typical at MELVILLE
2
On par with station median (2)
Median of 43 inspections at this station in the trailing 12 months

How this compares

National peer benchmarks for inspections at this level.

Violations vs Level 3 median
2
2 more than the median (0)
Compared to 637,721 Level 3 inspections nationwide in 2023
OOS at this inspection
Yes
Cohort OOS rate: 4.8%
Out-of-service rate across all Level 3 inspections in 2023
Carrier clean-inspection rate (12 mo)
25%
16 inspections in the trailing 12 months
Computed from this carrier's inspection history

Carrier trend at this moment

How active was this carrier's inspection record around this date?

Prior 30 days
3
12 violations · 2 OOS
Prior 90 days
8
14 violations · 2 OOS · 1.75 per inspection
Prior 365 days
16
34 violations · 6 OOS · 2.13 per inspection
Honest opinion

An out-of-service order is one of the most consequential outcomes a roadside inspection can produce — the most heavily-weighted OOS citation here was 383.23(a)(2) (Operating a CMV without a CDL, severity weight 8). (383.23(a)(2))

Units Inspected

1 unit(s) covered by this inspection.

Seq Type VIN Plate Make Model Year OOS
1 STRAIGHT TRUCK 1FVACXBS5BDAX7744 NY 58287MK FREIGHTLINER M2 2011

Violations Cited

2 violation(s) recorded against this inspection.

Code Description Severity Wt BASIC OOS
383.23(a)(2) Operating a CMV without a CDL 8 Driver Fitness OOS
396.17(c) Operating a CMV without proof of a periodic inspection 4 Vehicle Maintenance

Violation categories (BASICs)

Federal behavior-analysis-and-safety-improvement buckets for the cited violations.

Nearby inspections (same carrier, ±60 days)

Other times this carrier was inspected around the same date.

Inspection Date State Level Location Violations OOS
80139730 Nov 9, 2023 NY L2 1
80102144 Nov 7, 2023 NY L3 SEAFORD NY 0
80086772 Nov 4, 2023 NY L1 SOUTHAMPTON NY 12 OOS
80034792 Oct 30, 2023 NY L3 WOODBURY NY 0
80013174 Oct 26, 2023 NY L3 PLAINVIEW NY 0
80013464 Oct 24, 2023 NY L3 PLAINVIEW NY 0

Related records

Recent activity at MELVILLE

Other carriers inspected here recently.

Inspection Date Carrier Violations OOS
82803265 Sep 30, 2024 TIERNEY & COURTNEY OVERHEAD DOOR SALES CO INC 0
82791795 Sep 27, 2024 NICOLA DESIGN STUDIO 2
82755190 Sep 25, 2024 HERNANDEZ TREE CARE SERVICE 4
82755233 Sep 23, 2024 ELITE EXTERIORS CONSTRUCTION CORP 9 OOS
82755232 Sep 23, 2024 HARLEN HOME IMPROVEMENT CORP 11 OOS
82584263 Sep 3, 2024 HIGHWAY SAFETY PROTECTION CORP 0