Roadside Inspection 79726178

Roadside inspection on Sep 21, 2023 in New York • Carrier: WINTERS BROS HAULING OF LONG ISLAND LLC (USDOT 2483208) • Vehicle: MACK TRUCK TRACTOR

Vehicle OOS Driver: OK CVSA L1
Units Inspected
2
Total Violations
4
OOS Violations
1
25% of violations
Inspection Level
Level 1

Inspection Details

Key facts from the FMCSA inspection record.

Inspection #:
79726178
Date:
Sep 21, 2023
State:
New York
Type:
Units inspected:
2
Violations:
4
HazMat:
No
Reported location:
5800 SUNRISE HWY SERVICE SAYVI
Vehicle:
MACK Pinnacle TRUCK TRACTOR
Plate:
76230PC (NY)

What this inspection means

The vehicle was placed out of service at this inspection.

Cited issues fall mainly under Vehicle Maintenance, with a combined severity weight of 14.

Compared to the median Level 1 inspection nationwide in 2023, this is a more severe than typical result.

Severity context

How mild, normal, or severe was this inspection compared to its carrier, state, and station?

vs this carrier's typical
4
Heavier than carrier average
Carrier averages 2.10 violations per inspection across 20 prior records
vs Level 1 median in New York
4
Heavier than median (2)
Median of 13,733 Level 1 inspections in New York during 2023

How this compares

National peer benchmarks for inspections at this level.

Violations vs Level 1 median
4
3 more than the median (1)
Compared to 536,564 Level 1 inspections nationwide in 2023
OOS at this inspection
Yes
Cohort OOS rate: 24.6%
Out-of-service rate across all Level 1 inspections in 2023
Carrier clean-inspection rate (12 mo)
20%
20 inspections in the trailing 12 months
Computed from this carrier's inspection history

Carrier trend at this moment

How active was this carrier's inspection record around this date?

Prior 30 days
5
9 violations · 1 OOS
Prior 90 days
11
22 violations · 3 OOS · 2.00 per inspection
Prior 365 days
20
42 violations · 7 OOS · 2.10 per inspection
Honest opinion

An out-of-service order is one of the most consequential outcomes a roadside inspection can produce — the most heavily-weighted OOS citation here was 393.45(d) (Brake connections with leaks or constrictions, severity weight 4). (393.45(d))

Units Inspected

2 unit(s) covered by this inspection.

Seq Type VIN Plate Make Model Year OOS
1 TRUCK TRACTOR 1M1PN4GY1LM004753 NY 76230PC MACK Pinnacle 2020
2 SEMI-TRAILER 56EA75K2XPA000049 ME 5029754 ARMOR LITE TRAILER Armor Lite Trailer 2023

Violations Cited

4 violation(s) recorded against this inspection.

Code Description Severity Wt BASIC OOS
393.45(d) Brake connections with leaks or constrictions 4 Vehicle Maintenance OOS
393.55(d)(3) No or Defective ABS Malfunction Indicator for towed vehicles on vehicles manufactured after February 2001 4 Vehicle Maintenance
393.9(a) Inoperable required lamps 3 Vehicle Maintenance
393.9(a) Inoperable required lamps 3 Vehicle Maintenance

Violation categories (BASICs)

Federal behavior-analysis-and-safety-improvement buckets for the cited violations.

Nearby inspections (same carrier, ±60 days)

Other times this carrier was inspected around the same date.

Inspection Date State Level Location Violations OOS
80139730 Nov 9, 2023 NY L2 1
80102144 Nov 7, 2023 NY L3 SEAFORD NY 0
80086772 Nov 4, 2023 NY L1 SOUTHAMPTON NY 12 OOS
80034792 Oct 30, 2023 NY L3 WOODBURY NY 0
80013174 Oct 26, 2023 NY L3 PLAINVIEW NY 0
80013464 Oct 24, 2023 NY L3 PLAINVIEW NY 0

Related records